Need a Second Opinion for Your Worker’s Compensation Claim?

When you’re injured on the job, navigating the workers’ compensation system can be challenging, especially when it involves your health and recovery. Understanding your right to a second medical opinion can be crucial to ensuring you receive appropriate care and treatment for your injuries.

Understanding Your Right to a Second Opinion

If you’ve been injured at work and have filed a workers’ compensation claim, you will likely be examined by a doctor chosen by your employer’s insurance provider. However, there might be instances where you disagree with the doctor’s assessment, whether about your capacity to work or the recommended treatment plan. So, what can you do if you find yourself in this situation?

Your Rights in New Jersey

In New Jersey, while you don’t have an automatic “right” to a second opinion funded by the workers’ compensation insurer, you’re allowed to request one. The decision to grant and pay for a second opinion is at the insurer’s discretion. This means that although you can seek a second opinion independently, you may be responsible for the associated costs unless the insurer agrees to cover them.

Financial Considerations

The likelihood of the insurance company agreeing to a second opinion often hinges on the financial implications. If the initial evaluation suggests no need for further treatment, thereby incurring no additional costs for the insurer, they might not authorize a second opinion. However, if the treatment involves significant expenses, such as surgery, the insurer might be more inclined to consider a second opinion.

The Impact of a Second Opinion

A second opinion can be crucial, particularly when challenging a denied workers’ compensation claim. During the appeal process, the insights and recommendations from a second opinion can be presented as compelling evidence, potentially influencing the outcome in your favor. By providing an alternative evaluation, this second opinion ensures that all aspects of your condition and treatment options are thoroughly considered, aiming to secure a treatment plan that aligns with your health needs and rights under the workers’ compensation system.

Why Choose Dr. Gatto for Your Second Opinion?

In choosing Dr. Charles A. Gatto for your second opinion, particularly for work-related spinal injuries, you’re entrusting your care to a highly qualified professional whose expertise stands out in the field of orthopedic spine surgery. With over 21 years of experience, Dr. Gatto brings a depth of knowledge and a comprehensive approach to diagnosing and treating spinal conditions that are both rare and reassuring.

Schedule an Appointment

Schedule an appointment with Dr. Gatto today to ensure that your treatment plan aligns with your health needs and maximizes your recovery potential. Remember, your well-being is the top priority, and getting a second opinion can be critical in safeguarding your health and future.


1. Can I get a second medical opinion if I disagree with the doctor provided by my employer’s insurance?

In New Jersey, you have the right to request a second opinion, but the workers’ compensation insurance carrier is not automatically required to pay for it. If you choose to get a second opinion at your own expense and it differs from the initial evaluation, you can submit the findings to the insurance carrier for consideration.

2. Will workers’ compensation insurance pay for my second medical opinion?

The payment for a second opinion depends on the discretion of the workers’ compensation insurance carrier. While you are entitled to seek a second opinion, the insurer may not cover the cost unless it deems the additional consultation necessary.

3. How does a second opinion affect my workers’ compensation claim?

A second opinion can provide additional insights into your injury, potentially altering your treatment plan and affecting your eligibility for certain benefits or the compensation you receive. If this opinion suggests a different diagnosis or treatment, it can be submitted to the insurance carrier for review. While the carrier is not obligated to change its stance based on the second opinion, the information can be crucial if you decide to appeal a decision or dispute the claim.

4. What should I do if the workers’ compensation insurer refuses to authorize a second opinion?

If the insurer refuses to authorize or pay for a second opinion and you believe it is necessary for your care, you may need to consult with a workers’ compensation attorney to explore your options, which might include paying out of pocket or contesting the insurer’s decision.

5. Can I choose any doctor for my second opinion?

While you generally have the right to seek a second opinion, some states or insurance policies may have specific guidelines about which doctors you can see. It’s often recommended to choose a doctor like Dr. Gatto, who is experienced in workers’ compensation cases and familiar with the laws in your state, to ensure their opinion is well-respected and considered in your claim.

Dr. Charles A. Gatto is a board-certified, fellowship-trained orthopedic spine surgeon who specializes in all aspects of spine surgery.


© 2024 Charles Gatto MD All Rights Reserved.